🛒 Shirley · Suffolk County

Pet Stores in Shirley, NY

We've verified 2 pet stores serving Shirley, NY. Independent pet shops and chains serving Shirley. Locals know the small shops carry better food, raw and frozen options, and real product knowledge. The top-rated option in Shirley is currently 4.6★. Each listing has the phone, hours, and Google reviews — click any card to see the full profile.

Verified pet stores

4.6

Top rating

Mobile pros

Top pet stores in Shirley

Sorted by rating · 2 results

Shirley Feed & Pet

★ 4.6(951)·Shirley

Shirley Feed & Pet is a pet stores & supplie located in Shirley. With more than 951 Google reviews, they're one of the most-reviewed pet stores & supplies in Shirley. Currently averaging 4.6 stars on Google. Like most pet stores & supplies in the Shirley area, services typically include beds and crates, aquarium and reptile supplies, flea and tick prevention, premium and raw food. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “First time here and I am sorry i have not gone there sooner. I will return. Extremely large selection and staff is great. Prices are great. Highly recommend. I purchased nutri-source puppy food which is very hard to find in eastern Suffolk County.” — William Ryan McCaffrey On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open seven days. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Shirley.

Call Map

Pets Warehouse Shirley

★ 4.2(88)·Shirley

Pets Warehouse Shirley is a pet stores & supplie serving Shirley and the surrounding area. Steadily growing — 88 Google reviews and counting. Currently averaging 4.2 stars. Like most pet stores & supplies in the Shirley area, services typically include beds and crates, pet bakery and treats, premium and raw food, toys and enrichment. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “This store always has everything I need. I have 3 dogs and they don't eat the same food.. it's nice to be able to get everything in one place. The staff always greet you kindly when you walk in, and they are always ready to help you when you need assistance.” — Jody Lorrens On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open seven days. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, debit cards accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Shirley.

Call Map