Pet Stores in Bay Shore, NY

All Animals Pet Food & Supply is a pet stores & supplie serving East Islip and the surrounding area. A smaller, locally-rooted operation with 27 reviews on record. Currently averaging 4.8 stars on Google. On the services side, their own site highlights What We Carry, We Deliver, and Coupons And Specials. Specific availability, breeds handled, and pricing are best confirmed by calling — most local pet stores & supplies prefer to talk through what you need before quoting. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “Owners of this local pet shop is amazing! They recommended the best food, toys and other much needed supplies for my six month old goldendoodle puppy. Thanks to them I always find the best items for my puppy for very reasonable prices.” — Ipek Basaran On scheduling: Saturday hours but closed Sunday, open six days a week. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in East Islip.

Repxotica, Inc is a pet stores & supplie a West Islip-based operation. 268 Google reviews put them among the highest-volume pet stores & supplies in the area. Currently averaging 4.7 stars on Google. Like most pet stores & supplies in the West Islip area, services typically include beds and crates, pet bakery and treats, toys and enrichment, premium and raw food. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “I love this place. Owners and workers are very knowledgeable and down to earth. They gave me some really good advice for our crested gecko. I didnt buy dart from repxotica. But I do get my food for him there since the place i bought ours at went ouf of buisness. They have a nice…” — sassy kat On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open seven days. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in West Islip.

Pet Supplies Plus Central Islip is a pet stores & supplie based in Central Islip, NY. With more than 547 Google reviews, they're one of the most-reviewed pet stores & supplies in Central Islip. Currently averaging 4.6 stars on Google. Like most pet stores & supplies in the Central Islip area, services typically include flea and tick prevention, aquarium and reptile supplies, beds and crates, premium and raw food. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “Love this store for 2 Golden Retrievers Hazel & Rocky. I get their food, toys, treats & any other accessories. What I like most about Pet Supplies Plus is their washing stations I use during cold weather months. Always clean, towels to use & shampoo. Makes giving them a bath so…” — Kelly Heins On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open seven days. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Central Islip.

Fluid Dynamics Aquarium Services and Store is a pet stores & supplie serving Deer Park and the surrounding area. Steadily growing — 137 Google reviews and counting. Their 5.0-star average is rare at that volume — locals consistently report a positive experience. On the services side, their own site highlights Highly-dependable, Long Island Aquarium Services, Trusted By National Brands, We’re just a call or click away, Fresh Water, and Salt Water. Specific availability, breeds handled, and pricing are best confirmed by calling — most local pet stores & supplies prefer to talk through what you need before quoting. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “Clean, knowledgeable staff good fish at the store. They have done a fantastic job maintaining my 800 gallon salt water tank! Never had a issue with these guys and they are always there fast when something goes wrong.” — Don’t worry about it On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, debit cards accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Deer Park.

Underground Aquaticz is a pet stores & supplie a West Babylon-based operation. Steadily growing — 121 Google reviews and counting. Their 4.9-star average is rare at that volume — locals consistently report a positive experience. Like most pet stores & supplies in the West Babylon area, services typically include beds and crates, toys and enrichment, aquarium and reptile supplies, premium and raw food. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, debit cards accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in West Babylon.

Koi fish / C’s Aquarium is a pet stores & supplie based in Hauppauge, NY. A smaller, locally-rooted operation with 21 reviews on record. Currently averaging 4.8 stars. Like most pet stores & supplies in the Hauppauge area, services typically include beds and crates, aquarium and reptile supplies, pet bakery and treats, premium and raw food. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “Great mix of fish & plants and can order if they don’t have what you want. I had a great convo with Adam who helped me decide how and when to add stock to my new tank and he got me started. I will be back for sure!” — Steve S Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Hauppauge.

TIA Collection Corals (Tropical Island Aquatics) Saltwater Only is a pet stores & supplie located in Deer Park. Steadily growing — 193 Google reviews and counting. Currently averaging 4.7 stars on Google. On the services side, their own site highlights Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok. Specific availability, breeds handled, and pricing are best confirmed by calling — most local pet stores & supplies prefer to talk through what you need before quoting. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “Stopped by for some fish and corals for my 200g reef tank and was very impressed at their selection, this by far has been the best saltwater fish store I have been to in Long Island! Very clean Fish are healthy Corals are healthy Prices are great ! Everyone in Long Island and…” — Randy P On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open six days a week. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Deer Park.

Pets Warehouse is a pet stores & supplie a Bohemia-based operation. Steadily growing — 132 Google reviews and counting. Currently averaging 4.3 stars. Like most pet stores & supplies in the Bohemia area, services typically include pet bakery and treats, flea and tick prevention, toys and enrichment, beds and crates. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “This is such a great pet supply store. I picked up some items for my kitten today and the store associate named Julia was so helpful with me, and very knowledgeable about animals too.” — Cassandra D On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open seven days. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Bohemia.

South Shore Tropicals is a pet stores & supplie located in Lindenhurst. 368 Google reviews put them among the highest-volume pet stores & supplies in the area. Their 4.8-star average is rare at that volume — locals consistently report a positive experience. Like most pet stores & supplies in the Lindenhurst area, services typically include aquarium and reptile supplies, pet bakery and treats, flea and tick prevention, premium and raw food. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently. In their own words, a recent 5-star reviewer wrote: “I’ve been going since pre pandemic. I love to support local family owned places and this is the goods…. I get the best angel fish; arrowana ; red devil ciclids; rocks supplies frozen food all here. I love this place . Bryan salamone” — teamsalamone On scheduling: they're open both Saturday and Sunday, open seven days. Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Lindenhurst.