About Creepy Creatures
Creepy Creatures is a pet stores & supplie serving Farmingdale and the surrounding area. 263 Google reviews put them among the highest-volume pet stores & supplies in the area. Currently averaging 4.5 stars on Google.
Like most pet stores & supplies in the Farmingdale area, services typically include aquarium and reptile supplies, pet bakery and treats, premium and raw food, toys and enrichment. Confirm what's available for your specific situation by calling — every shop runs a little differently.
Accessibility & payment: wheelchair-accessible parking, Apple/Google Pay accepted. Use the Call button above to reach them directly, or tap Map for directions in Farmingdale.
Wheelchair accessibleApple/Google PayVerified
What a recent customer said
★★★★★
“I’m having trouble getting my bearded dragon to vary his diet and I went into Creepy Creatures to see if they sold anything that I haven’t already tried (I’ve tried everything). The staff member running the store (may be the owner) explained why I was having an issue and did not…”
— Melanie Drewes, Google review